Why can’t we all just get along?

Dylan Matthews has a brilliant post up on the Washington Post‘s Wonkblog where he’s taken a piece written by liberal Jesse Myerson for Rolling Stone and rewritten it as a conservative wish list, while keeping the underlying policies the same. The five policies are (liberal / conservative):

  1. Guaranteed jobs / Making welfare recipients work for the government
  2. Universal basic income / Replacing welfare with a single payment to all taxpayers
  3. Government land ownership / Land-value tax
  4. Nationalisation of US businesses / Sovereign wealth fund
  5. Nationalised banks / Enterprise investment banks

While Dylan uses his post to show how important tribalism is in politics, it also highlights what I think is a more fundamental division in politics: pragmatism vs idealism. All of these policies fail, at least in the way they’ve been presented, either because they are politically untenable or because they grossly oversimplify all of the underlying issues:

  1. ‘Make-work’ programmes are inevitably inefficient, because if the ... Read More